The Florida Keys are steeped in history, from shipwrecks to hidden treasures, but few stories are as intriguing as the legend behind the name of Doctors Arm. Nestled on Big Pine Key, this quiet residential area has a past that harks back to the era of pirates and high-seas adventure.
A Pirate’s Refuge in Pine Channel
The tale begins with a band of pirates who frequently anchored in Pine Channel, using the area as a temporary refuge after their raids. Among their latest captives was a doctor, a man by the name of Armondo Guessipie. Following a particularly violent attack, several members of the crew were wounded and in dire need of medical attention.
When the pirate captain discovered that one of the prisoners was a doctor, he saw an opportunity to save his men. He ordered Armondo to tend to the wounded, but the doctor, whether out of defiance or principle, refused. His refusal enraged the captain, who decided to maroon him on a nearby island as punishment.
From ‘Doctors Armondi’ to ‘Doctors Arm’
The island became known among the crew as “Doctors Armondi Island,” named after the ill-fated doctor who was left to survive on his own. Over the years, the name evolved, eventually becoming “Doctors Arm.” The story, passed down through generations, was later revived in the 1940s when real estate developer Tom Denali heard the legend. Captivated by the history, he decided to name his subdivision in honor of the long-forgotten doctor and the tale of resilience and defiance that shaped the area’s identity.
A Name Steeped in Lore
While the true fate of Dr. Armondo Guessipie remains a mystery—was he rescued, did he perish, or did he carve out an existence in isolation?—the legacy of his name endures. Whether fact or embellished legend, the tale of Doctors Arm adds another layer to the rich, mysterious history of the Florida Keys, reminding us of the days when pirates ruled the waters and every cove held a secret.
Next time you find yourself in Big Pine Key, take a moment to reflect on the history beneath your feet. You never know what other stories might be waiting to be uncovered.
For more information on our services CLICK HERE!
